Skip to main content
All Insights

Recruited for Fraud

GovIntegrityNovember 16, 2026
Recruited for Fraud

From Arizona’s sober-living scandal to Florida’s ACA enrollment scheme, criminal enterprises have turned vulnerable Americans into the raw material for billions in fraudulent government payments. But we aren’t hearing much about them.

When Anders Hustito asked how his son could have been drinking inside a home that was supposed to be treating his alcoholism, he was told that residents were allowed to drink a little to calm down. His son, Jeffrey, a 43-year-old from Zuni Pueblo, New Mexico, had gone to Arizona hoping treatment would help him get and keep a job. He died in a sober-living home in December 2022, all the while Medicaid had been paying for his “care.”

The Trump administration has made government fraud a priority and frequently highlights the identities and backgrounds of the accused. In Minnesota, where federal prosecutors have uncovered extensive fraud in social service programs, the administration has repeatedly emphasized the Somali ancestry of many defendants and tied the prosecutions to its broader immigration agenda.

But some of the most damaging schemes recruit real people, chosen because they are homeless, addicted, poor, or mentally ill, and convert their identities and eligibility into government payments. The consequences are far more than stolen public funds—people have experienced serious physical harm and even death through these fraud schemes. Two examples drive home the impacts.

Arizona Sober Living Fraud

Beginning around 2019, a sprawling network of sham behavioral health clinics and sober-living homes took root in Arizona, exploiting the state’s Medicaid program and, in particular, its American Indian Health Program. Recruiters went to reservations and city streets, approaching people struggling with homelessness and addiction and promising housing, meals, and treatment. Some were driven hundreds of miles to the Phoenix area, hoping treatment would help them rebuild their lives.

What they found were overcrowded, poorly supervised homes where little or no meaningful treatment took place. Some operators tolerated or even supplied alcohol and drugs to the people they were billing Medicaid to treat. Investigators documented allegations of coercion and neglect, and some were even made to feel as if they couldn’t leave.

Meanwhile, clinics billed Medicaid for counseling, intensive outpatient programs, and other services that were never delivered or were grossly inflated, and they paid sober-living operators to keep the beds full. Because it is fee-for-service, the American Indian Health Program was an especially easy target. Unlike the managed care plans that cover most Arizona Medicaid members, the program lets providers bill the state directly for each service, with no health plan reviewing claims in between. According to the Arizona Attorney General, the program recorded roughly $3.1 billion in behavioral health billing from 2021 to 2023. The state’s Medicaid agency has acknowledged the fraud cost taxpayers as much as $2.5 billion.

But those numbers say nothing of the human toll. In January 2025, ProPublica and the Arizona Center for Investigative Reporting documented at least 40 Native American residents of Phoenix-area sober-living homes and treatment facilities who died between spring 2022 and summer 2024, nearly all from drugs or alcohol. The reporters found that officials in both Republican and Democratic administrations had received repeated warnings and failed to act. Community advocates believe the true toll, counting people who died after leaving or being expelled from these homes, is far higher.

Jeffrey Hustito’s experience illusrtaes that of scores of others. He moved among facilities, lost touch with his family for stretches, and was repeatedly taken to emergency rooms for alcohol poisoning, then released back to the same sober-living home, which was billing Medicaid the whole time.

When the state finally moved in May 2023, the crackdown created a second emergency. Arizona’s Medicaid agency has since suspended payments to more than 300 providers. Homes closed almost overnight, and thousands of legitimate residents needed emergency help with housing, transportation, or getting home to their tribal communities. Some legitimate providers were wrongfully accused and patients who relied on them went months without care. The scandal exposed failures in provider screening, licensing, rate oversight, and any real check that billed services were delivered.

Florida Affordable Care Act Fraud

A separate scheme in the Affordable Care Act marketplace used a different mechanism but the same raw material. In November 2025, a federal jury in Miami convicted Cory Lloyd, president of an insurance brokerage, and Steven Strong, CEO of a marketing company, for a scheme that sought more than $233 million in fraudulent ACA premium subsidies. The government paid out at least $180 million. Prosecutors called it the largest ACA enrollment fraud case ever brought to trial. In February 2026, both men were sentenced to 20 years in prison and ordered to pay $180.6 million in restitution.

According to the Justice Department, the defendants targeted tens of thousands of people experiencing homelessness, unemployment, addiction, mental illness, and financial hardship. Street marketers approached them, sometimes offering cash or other inducements, and signed them up for health plans. Every enrollment resulted in a broker commission, paid for with federal subsidy dollars.

The problem was that many recruits had little or no income and did not qualify for the subsidies the defendants were after. So, the fraudsters falsified income, coached applicants with scripts about expected earnings, and manipulated the enrollment process to obtain fully subsidized coverage. They also submitted Medicaid applications designed to be denied, which let them enroll people in ACA plans outside the normal open enrollment period. The proceeds, predictably, went to luxury vehicles, an oceanfront home in the Florida Keys, and an 80-foot yacht.

Text messages introduced at trial showed how the defendants belittled the people they recruited and how they discussed sending street marketers into Florida hurricane shelters to find more. For those enrolled, the consequences were serious. Some lost existing Medicaid coverage or saw their care disrupted. According to the Justice Department, the scheme put people at risk of losing access to lifesaving treatment for opioid use disorder, mental health conditions, and serious infectious diseases. The scheme worked because brokers controlled the income and enrollment information on the applications, and government controls did not catch the resulting pattern of suspicious enrollments quickly enough.

The Human Toll

Fraud against benefit programs often depends on deliberately exploiting the people those programs exist to serve. In Arizona, Native Americans struggling with addiction were recruited into facilities that profited from their Medicaid coverage while failing to care for them. In Florida, people experiencing homelessness, addiction, and mental illness were enrolled in plans that paid brokers while putting their own treatment at risk. In both cases, the perpetrators understood their targets’ vulnerabilities and built a business model around them.

The administration has made the Somali ancestry of Minnesota defendants a prominent part of its messaging. But the systematic exploitation of Native Americans, dozens of whom died after entering facilities that promised to help them, has received far less national attention. The messaging begs the question: why does the identity of the perpetrators so often become the story, while the identity and experience of the victims isn’t talked about?

Much of the damage caused by these schemes was preventable. In Arizona, the warning signs were in the state’s own data. Behavioral health spending was climbing steeply, and providers were billing extraordinary amounts for routine services. Licensing and screening requirements had been loosened, and officials received repeated warnings about specific facilities. A functioning fraud risk management system would have flagged these patterns, investigated high-risk providers, and intervened before the schemes scaled. In Florida, brokers manipulated self-reported income to obtain subsidies for ineligible people and exploited gaps between Medicaid eligibility determinations and ACA enrollment rules. Real income verification, tighter controls on broker activity, and monitoring for unusual enrollment patterns would have made the scheme far harder to run.

Both cases also show that fraud controls must be designed with beneficiaries in mind. When Arizona cut off payments, many residents lost housing and treatment overnight. Effective enforcement needs a plan for the legitimate people inside the system being shut down. All that is required is better use of data agencies already have, stronger oversight of providers and intermediaries, timely action on suspicious activity, and clear accountability for responding to warnings. But above all, officials need to treat fraud prevention as a priority.

Protecting Taxpayers and the People Programs Serve

Government fraud deserves the senior level attention it is getting, but the conversation is incomplete without talking about the victims. The Arizona and Florida cases show fraudsters seeking out the people least able to protect themselves, using promises of housing, treatment, cash, or insurance to get access, and government payments to keep the operation growing.

The response should include vigorous prosecution and recovery of stolen funds, yes, but also reforms that make the next scheme harder, like verifying eligibility and services, monitoring providers and brokers, investigating suspicious patterns early, and making sure exploited people get help. If we want fraud prevention that protects both taxpayers and the people public programs are meant to serve, we need to focus less on the immigration status of the alleged perpetrators and more on how the schemes are being carried out, the impacts of those schemes on real people, and how we can stop them.


Photo by Matt Collamer on Unsplash. Article first posted on GovIntegrity.